logo

Bitcoin in the Shadow of a Trade War: How to Find a Balance Between Risk and Hedging?

By: blockbeats|2025/03/18 06:15:03
分享
copy
Original Article Title: "Bitcoin in the Shadow of Trade Wars: How to Find a Balance Between Risk and Hedge?"
Original Article Author: Andrew Singer, Block Unicorn

Bitcoin in the Shadow of a Trade War: How to Find a Balance Between Risk and Hedging?

A few years ago, many in the crypto community described Bitcoin as a "hedge" asset. Today, fewer people use that term to describe it.

A hedge asset retains or increases in value during times of economic stress. It can be government bonds, currencies like the US dollar, commodities like gold, or even blue-chip stocks.

The US-led global trade war and unsettling economic reports have led to stock market crashes, and Bitcoin has followed suit – something that should not happen to a "hedge" asset.

Bitcoin has also underperformed compared to gold. "Since January 1, the price of gold has risen +10%, while Bitcoin has fallen -10%," the Kobeissi Letter pointed out on March 3. "Cryptocurrency is no longer seen as a hedge tool." (Bitcoin fell even more last week.)

But some market observers say this is not entirely unexpected.

Bitcoin (white) and Gold (yellow) price chart from December 1 to March 13. Source: Bitcoin Counter Flow

Was Bitcoin Ever a Hedge Asset?

"I have never considered Bitcoin a 'hedge asset,'" Paul Schatz, Founder and President of Heritage Capital, told us. "The volatility of Bitcoin is too great to fit into the hedge category, although I do believe investors can and should have an overall allocation to this asset class."

"To me, Bitcoin is still a speculative tool, not a hedge asset," Jochen Stanz, Chief Market Analyst at CMC Markets (Germany), told us. "Hedge investments like gold have intrinsic value that will never be zero. Bitcoin could drop 80% in a major correction. I don't think gold will do that."

"Cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin, have never been a hedge tool in my opinion," Buvaneshwaran Venugopal, Assistant Professor of Finance at the University of Central Florida, told us.

However, things are not always as clear-cut as they may initially seem, especially when it comes to cryptocurrency.

People may think of different types of safe-haven assets: one for geopolitical events such as war, pandemics, and economic downturns, and another for severe financial events such as bank failures or a weakening US dollar.

The perception of Bitcoin may be shifting. By 2024, with the issuance of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) from major asset management companies like BlackRock and Fidelity, it is being included, broadening its ownership base but potentially also altering its 'narrative'.

Now, it is more widely seen as a speculative or 'risk-on' asset, akin to tech stocks.

"Bitcoin and the entire cryptocurrency space have become highly correlated with risk assets and are usually inversely correlated to safe-haven assets like gold," Adam Kobeissi, editor of the Kobeissi Letter, told us.

He further noted that with "more institutional involvement and leverage," there is significant uncertainty about Bitcoin's future, and the narrative has shifted from Bitcoin being seen as 'digital gold' to a more speculative asset.

People might think that the acceptance by traditional financial giants like BlackRock and Fidelity would make Bitcoin's future more secure, enhancing its safe-haven narrative - but according to Venugopal, this is not the case:

"The entry of large corporations into Bitcoin does not make it safer. In fact, it means that Bitcoin is becoming more like any other asset institutional investors tend to invest in."

Venugopal continued to say that it would be more influenced by the regular trading and drawdown strategies used by institutional investors. "If there is anything different, Bitcoin is now more correlated with risk assets in the market."

Bitcoin's Dual Nature

Few would argue against Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies still being subject to significant price swings, recently driven by increased retail adoption of cryptocurrency, particularly fueled by the meme coin craze, which, as Kobeissi pointed out, is one of the largest cryptocurrency onboarding events in history. But perhaps that is the wrong focus.

"Safe-haven assets are always long-term assets, which means short-term volatility is not an intrinsic feature," Noelle Acheson, author of the Crypto is Macro Now newsletter, told us.

The biggest question is whether Bitcoin can maintain its value against fiat currency in the long term, and it has already been able to do so. "Its digital proof of work is proven—it has outperformed gold and U.S. stocks in almost any four-year time frame," Acheson said, adding:

“Bitcoin has always had two key narratives: it is a short-term risk asset, sensitive to liquidity expectations and overall sentiment. It is also a long-term store of value. It can be both, as we are seeing.”

Another possibility is that Bitcoin may be a hedge asset for certain events but not for others.

Gold can serve as a hedge against geopolitical issues (such as trade wars), and both Bitcoin and gold can serve as hedges against inflation. "Therefore, both are useful hedge assets in a portfolio," Kendrick added.

Others, including Ark Investment's Cathie Wood, also agreed that Bitcoin acted as a hedge asset during the run on SVB and Signature banks in March 2023. According to CoinGecko data, when SVB collapsed on March 10, 2023, Bitcoin was priced at around $20,200. A week later, it was close to $27,400, up about 35%.

Bitcoin price fell on March 10 and rebounded a week later. Source: CoinGecko

Schatz does not believe that Bitcoin is a tool to hedge against inflation. The events of 2022, when FTX and other crypto companies collapsed, marking the beginning of the crypto winter, "severely challenged this argument."

Perhaps it is a tool to hedge against the U.S. dollar and treasuries? "This is possible, but these scenarios are quite bleak and hard to imagine," Schatz added.

Don't Overreact

Kobeissi agrees that short-term volatility in asset classes "is usually the least correlated over long-term timeframes." Despite some recent pullback, many of Bitcoin's fundamentals remain positive: a crypto-friendly U.S. government, announcements of U.S. Bitcoin reserves, and the surge in cryptocurrency adoption.

The biggest issue facing market participants is: "What is the next major catalyst for upward momentum?" Kobeissi told us. "This is the reason for market pullbacks and consolidation: looking for the next major catalyst."

“Since macro investors started viewing Bitcoin as a high-volatility, liquidity-sensitive risk asset, it has behaved like a risk asset,” Acheson added. Furthermore, “It’s almost always short-term traders setting the final price, and if they’re in the process of unwinding risk assets, we’ll see weakness in Bitcoin.”

The market overall is struggling. “The reappearance of the inflation specter and a severe economic slowdown have greatly impacted expectations,” which has also affected Bitcoin’s price. Acheson further noted:

“Given this backdrop, and Bitcoin’s dual nature as both a risk asset and a long-term hedge, I’m surprised it didn’t drop further.”

Venugopal stated that Bitcoin hasn’t been a short-term hedge or safe haven asset since 2017. As for the long-standing argument of Bitcoin being digital gold due to its 21 million supply cap, this only holds true “if a majority of investors collectively expect Bitcoin to appreciate over time,” and “this may or may not be the case.”

Original Article Link

猜你喜歡

Trust Wallet 遭黑客攻擊最大損失達350萬美元

Key Takeaways 最大受害者損失了約350萬美元，該錢包已休眠一年。 第二大損失達140萬美元，該錢包已休眠兩年以上。 黑客共竊取超過600萬美元加密資產，其中超過400萬美元已轉移至CEX。 自托管錢包面臨基礎設施漏洞的潛在風險。 WEEX Crypto News, 26 December 2025 近期，Trust Wallet 發生了一起嚴重的黑客事件，此次事件引發了業界廣泛關注。在這起事件中，Trust Wallet的一個錢包損失了價值高達350萬美元的加密資產，該錢包在此次攻擊前已經休眠了一年多。此外，另一個損失較大的錢包也損失了約140萬美元，在攻擊發生前已經休眠超過兩年。 Trust Wallet…

项目方將40萬美元BDXN代幣注入多個交易所

Key Takeaways 三個BDXN項目方相關的錢包地址向多個交易所存入價值約40萬美元的BDXN代幣。 這些代幣於兩個月前從項目方的錢包轉出。 相關監測由onchainschool.pro 提供。 代幣轉移涉及的地址包括0xD5682dcA35D78c13b5103eB85c46cDCe28508dfB等。 WEEX Crypto News, 26 December 2025 BDXN項目方關聯錢包的最新動向 近期，BDXN項目方的部分地址將價值40萬美元的BDXN代幣注入多家交易所。據onchainschool.pro的監測顯示，與BDXN項目方相關的三個主要錢包在過去三小時內完成這一轉移操作，而這批代幣則早在兩個月前便從項目方錢包中轉出。 監測機構報告及相關地址詳情 這次轉移操作首次由onchainschool.pro監測到，並在ChainCatcher等多家媒體上披露。根據報告的數據，涉及到的三個錢包地址分別是：0xD5682dcA35D78c13b5103eB85c46cDCe28508dfB、0xD0Fc2894Dd2fe427a05980c2E3De8B7A89CB2672以及0xAc245a570A914C84300f24a07eb59425bbdC1B48。這些地址攜帶的代幣價值總計約40萬美元。 轉移代幣的未來意圖及市場影響…

# 龐貝與互聯網：Base 網絡上的 PancakeSwap V3 池中流動性獎勵啟動

Key Takeaways PancakeSwap 透過 Brevis Incentra 在 Base 網絡引入了 12 個 V3 池並開始提供流動性獎勵。 使用者可以在 Optimism 平台上通過 Incentra 添加流動性，不僅獲得交易費用，還能賺取…

代幣 VS 股權，Aave 爭議的來龍去脈

這是 Aave 要面對的問題，更是整個行業要面對的問題

12月26日市場關鍵情報，你錯過了多少？

1. 鏈上資金：本日有 7.8 百萬美元流入 Hyperliquid；5.5 百萬美元流出 Solana 2. 最大漲跌幅：$ISLM、$FTN 3. 熱門新聞：Trust Wallet 將確保所有受影響的用戶都能獲得退款，用戶需盡快完成程序升級

加密聖誕劫：損失超600萬美元，Trust Wallet 擴展錢包遭駭分析

Trust Wallet 瀏覽器擴充功能 2.68 版被發現存在惡意後門，導致用戶資金被盜，總損失超過 600 萬美元。

熱門幣種

最新加密貨幣要聞

08:46

美聯儲1月降息25個基點的概率小幅回升至17.7%

BlockBeats 消息，12 月 28 日，据 CME「美联储观察」数据，美联储明年 1 月降息 25 個基點的概率小幅回升至 17.7%，維持利率不變的概率為 82.3%。美聯儲至明年 3 月維持利率不變的概率為 46.7%，累計降息 25 個基點的概率為 45.6%，累計降息 50 個基點的概率為 7.7%。美聯儲接下來兩次 FOMC 會議日期分別為 2026 年 1 月 28 日、3 月 18 日。
08:46

山寨幣季節指數持續處於低位，暫報16

BlockBeats 消息，12 月 28 日，據 Coinmarketcap 數據，山寨幣季節指數（Altcoin Season Index）暫報 16，此前 9 月 20 日一度升至 78。該指數顯示在過去 90 天內，市值前 100 加密貨幣中約 16 個項目漲幅超越比特幣。注：CMC 加密貨幣山寨季指數是一個實時指標，用於判斷當前加密貨幣市場是否處於山寨幣主導的季節。該指數基於前 100 大山寨幣在過去 90 天內相對於比特幣的表現。
08:46

波段巨鯨「pension-usdt.eth」增持以太坊空單，持倉規模達7664萬美元

BlockBeats 消息，12 月 28 日，据 HyperInsight 监测，波段巨鯨「pension-usdt.eth」增持 6048 枚 ETH 空單，持倉規模達 26048 枚，約合 7664 萬美元，開倉價 2926 美元，浮虧 42 萬美元。另據監測，該地址常進行短時波段交易並以低槓桿全倉開設 BTC、ETH 主流幣種，平均持倉約 20 小時，近 30 天盈利約 1387 萬美元。
08:16

香港 2025 年十大財經新聞：「香港發展數位經濟虛擬資產監管框架趨完善」 位列第三

BlockBeats 消息，12 月 28 日，港媒《文汇报》公布《香港 2025 年十大財經新聞》，其中「發展數位經濟虛擬資產監管框架趨完善」位列第三，《穩定幣條例》出台進一步完善香港數位資產活動的監管框架，市場預期2026年初便會發出穩定幣牌照，港元穩定幣有望隨之面世將有利於實際商業貿易和跨境交易。此外「加密貨幣癲炒比特幣 12.56 萬美元新高」位列第八，特朗普高調支持比特幣讓其價格今年多次刷新歷史新高，不過目前已經回落並一度跌至約 8.5 萬美元水平，較高位下跌逾 30%。
07:33

輕量級：女巫帳戶的積分將重新分配給合格的交易者，未來將不再使用雙重代幣/股權結構。

BlockBeats 消息，12 月 28 日，Lighter 创始人兼 CEO Vladimir Novakovski 在今日社区 Space 中表示，反作弊算法使用数据科学和聚类方法来识别，目标并非真实用户，女巫账户的积分将重新分配给合格交易者。对女巫筛查设有申诉机制，目前为止申诉数量比预期的要少，如果用户觉得算法不公平，歡迎填寫 Discord 內建的申訴表格。具體算法細節將不會公開，因為不希望被針對性優化。Lighter 對最終女巫判定結果有信心，但如果確實存在誤判，請務必申訴。此外，向交易平臺轉移的大額代幣與空投無關，是為了保管投資者和團隊的分配份額。最終目標是使價值積累到代幣，而不...
閱讀更多
社區
iconiconiconiconiconiconiconicon

客戶服務：@weikecs

商務合作：@weikecs

量化做市商合作：[email protected]

VIP服務：[email protected]