From ETH to SOL: Why L1 Will Ultimately Lose to Bitcoin?
Original Article Title: Can L1s Compete Against BTC as Cryptomoney?
Original Article Author: AvgJoesCrypto, Messari
Original Article Translation: Ding Dang, Odaily Planet Daily
Editor's Note: Recently, Dragonfly Ventures' well-known partner Haseeb Qureshi published an article rejecting cynicism and embracing exponential thinking, unexpectedly bringing the community discussion back to the most core question: the value of L1, how much is left? The following content is excerpted from @MessariCrypto's upcoming "The Crypto Theses 2026," compiled by Odaily Planet Daily.
Cryptocurrency Driving the Entire Industry
Refocusing the discussion on "cryptocurrency" itself is crucial because most of the capital in the crypto industry is ultimately seeking exposure to "monetary assets." Currently, the total market capitalization of the crypto market is $3.26 trillion, with BTC accounting for $1.80 trillion, or 55%. Out of the remaining $1.45 trillion, approximately $0.83 trillion is concentrated in various L1 blockchains. In other words, about $2.63 trillion, approximately 81% of the entire market's funds, have been invested in assets that the market already considers money or believes may receive a future money premium.

In this context, whether you are a trader, investor, fund manager, or developer, understanding how the market bestows or withdraws a money premium is crucial. In the crypto industry, nothing drives valuation changes more than whether the market is willing to view an asset as "money." Therefore, predicting which assets may receive a money premium in the future is arguably the most important variable when constructing a portfolio.
So far, our main focus has been on BTC, but it is also necessary to discuss those L1 assets in the remaining $0.83 trillion that are "potentially money or not." As mentioned earlier, we expect BTC to continue absorbing market share from gold and other non-sovereign store-of-value assets in the coming years. However, this also raises a question: How much space is left for L1? When the tide rises, will all ships (assets) float (benefit)? Or will BTC, in its pursuit of gold, also draw some money premium from L1 blockchains?

To answer these questions, we first need to look at the current valuation landscape of L1. The top four L1s by market capitalization—ETH ($3611.5 billion), XRP ($1301.1 billion), BNB ($1206.4 billion), and SOL ($746.8 billion)—have a combined market capitalization of $6865.8 billion, representing 83% of the entire L1 sector. Beyond these top four, there is a significant market capitalization gap (e.g., TRX at $266.7 billion), but the tail-end volume is still substantial. The total market capitalization of L1s outside the top 15 is still $180.6 billion, accounting for 2% of the total L1 market capitalization.
More importantly, L1's market capitalization is not equivalent to pure "monetary premium." L1's valuation framework mainly consists of three types:
(i) Monetary Premium
(ii) Real Economic Value (REV)
(iii) Economic Security Demand
Therefore, a project's market capitalization is not solely determined by the market viewing it as a currency factor.
What drives L1 valuation is the monetary premium, not revenue
Despite the existence of multiple valuation frameworks, the market is increasingly inclined to evaluate L1 from the perspective of "monetary premium" rather than "revenue-driven." Over the past few years, all L1s with a market capitalization exceeding $1 billion have maintained an overall price-to-earnings ratio of roughly 150 to 200. However, this aggregate data is misleading as it includes TRON and Hyperliquid. In the past 30 days, TRX and HYPE contributed 70% of the revenue of this group but accounted for only 4% of the total market capitalization.

Excluding these two outliers, the true story emerges. While revenue continues to decline, L1's valuation is on the rise. The adjusted price-to-earnings ratio shows a clear upward trend:
· November 30, 2021: 40x
· November 30, 2022: 212x
· November 30, 2023: 137x
· November 30, 2024: 205x
· November 30, 2025: 536x
Interpreting this from the perspective of REV, one might think the market is pricing in future revenue growth. However, this interpretation doesn't hold because within the same group (excluding TRON and Hyperliquid), L1 revenue has been decreasing almost every year:
· 2021: $123.3 billion
· 2022: $48.9 billion (YoY -60%)
· 2023: $27.2 billion (YoY -44%)
· 2024: $35.5 billion (YoY +31%)
· 2025: Annualized $17.0 billion (YoY -52%)
In our view, the simplest and most direct explanation is: these valuations are primarily driven by currency premium rather than current or future revenue.
L1 Has Been Consistently Underperforming Bitcoin
If the valuation of L1 is primarily driven by market expectations of its currency premium, the next question is: what shapes this expectation? A simple way is to compare them with BTC's price performance. If changes in currency premium mainly reflect BTC's trend, the performance of these assets should be similar to BTC's 'β coefficient'; if the currency premium comes from each L1's unique factors, then their correlation with BTC should be weaker, and their performance should be more specific.

As a representative of L1, we selected the top ten market cap L1 tokens (excluding HYPE) and analyzed their performance relative to BTC since December 1, 2022. These ten assets account for approximately 94% of the L1 market cap, making them highly representative. During this period, eight assets have underperformed BTC in absolute return, with six lagging by over 40%. Only two assets outperformed BTC: XRP and SOL. However, XRP's excess return is only 3%, given its historically retail-dominated flows, which we won't read too much into. The asset that has truly significant excess returns is SOL, outperforming BTC by 87%.

However, a deeper analysis reveals that SOL's "outperformance" may not be as strong as it seems on the surface. During the same period where SOL outperformed BTC by 87%, the fundamental aspects of the Solana ecosystem saw an exponential growth: DeFi TVL increased by 2,988%, transaction fees grew by 1,983%, and DEX trading volume surged by 3,301%. By any reasonable measure, Solana's ecosystem has expanded by 20 to 30 times since the end of 2022, yet the corresponding SOL price only outpaced BTC by 87%.
Please read that sentence again.
In order to truly achieve significant outperformance against BTC in the game, an L1 network not only needs its ecosystem to grow by 200% or 300%—it needs to grow by 2,000%-3,000% just to barely attain a few tens of percentage points of excess performance.
Considering the above, our assessment is: While the market is still pricing L1 networks based on the expectation of "future potential currency premium," confidence in these expectations is quietly waning. At the same time, the market's premium on BTC as the "cryptocurrency" has not been shaken, and it can even be said that BTC's leading advantage over various L1 networks continues to expand.
Although cryptocurrencies themselves do not need transaction fees or revenue to support their valuation, these indicators are crucial for L1 networks. Unlike BTC, an L1 network's narrative depends on building an ecosystem (applications, users, throughput, economic activity, etc.) to support the value of its token. However, if an L1 network's ecosystem is showing annual decline (partially reflected in declining revenue and fees), then it loses its sole competitive advantage relative to BTC. Without real economic growth, its "cryptocurrency" story will become increasingly difficult for the market to accept.
Looking Ahead
Looking ahead, we do not believe this trend will reverse course in 2026 or beyond. With a few possible exceptions, we anticipate that the L1 sector will continue to lose market share, further squeezed by BTC. As its valuation primarily relies on the expectation of future currency premium, as the market gradually recognizes BTC's strongest claim to the narrative of "cryptocurrency," the valuation of L1 networks will continue to shrink. While BTC will also face challenges in the coming years, these issues are still too distant from reality and have too many variables to provide effective support for the currency premium of competing L1 networks.
errorYou may also like

Key Market Intelligence on December 30th, how much did you miss out on?

Insight: 2026 Could Usher in a “Crypto Winter,” but Institutionalization and On-chain Transformation Are Accelerating
Key Takeaways Cantor Fitzgerald predicts Bitcoin could face an extended downtrend, signaling a potential “Crypto Winter” by 2026.…

Caixin: Digital RMB Wallet Balances to Begin Earning Interest in 2026
Key Takeaways: Starting January 1, 2026, digital RMB wallets will earn interest on balances. The operational structure will…

Key Market Information Discrepancy on December 30th – A Must-See!
Key Takeaways Meta’s massive acquisition of Manus is poised to reshape the tech landscape, indicating significant growth in…

Cryptocurrency Trends and Insights: Navigating the 2025 Landscape
Key Takeaways Cryptocurrency continues to evolve rapidly, with new trends reshaping the market. Blockchain technology’s applications extend beyond…

Lighter: Airdrop Successful and Token Trading Imminent
Key Takeaways: The Lighter Discord community recently announced the successful distribution of LIT tokens, marking the beginning of…

UNI Burn Arbitrage Opportunity, Ondo Tokenized Stock Liquidity Debate, What’s the Overseas Crypto Community Talking About Today?
Key Takeaways The crypto market is buzzing with multi-threaded discussions, from macro trends to specific protocols and scams.…

Announcement: The Fed to Release Minutes of its Monetary Policy Meeting Soon
Key Takeaways The Federal Reserve is anticipated to disclose the minutes from its latest monetary policy meeting, offering…

The Fed’s Monetary Policy Minutes and the Crypto Trading Insights
Key Takeaways The Federal Reserve is set to disclose the minutes from its recent monetary policy meeting, highlighting…

“Elon Musk’s Nemesis Trade” Colossal ETH Short Sparks Debate in Crypto Circles
Key Takeaways A colossal short position was secured against Ethereum (ETH) worth approximately $106 million by a single…

Dragonfly Partner Foresees BTC Surpassing $150K by 2026 but Market Share Decline
Key Takeaways Bitcoin is anticipated to climb over $150,000 by the end of 2026, although its market dominance…

Elon Musk Liquidation Wall: Liquidates $106M Short Position, Faces $479K Loss
Key Takeaways A $106 million ETH short position was liquidated after just 15 hours, resulting in a $479,000…

Unstable Stablecoins: Understanding the Market’s Concerns and Dynamics
Key Takeaways Recent financial reports indicate concerns and instability in the stablecoin market. Circle, a leading stablecoin issuer,…
Market Update — December 30
Brevis opens airdrop tracking; Trend Research adds over 46,000 ETH in a single day.

BlockBeats 2025: Enabling 15 Million People to Witness Bitcoin's New All-Time High

Key Market Information Discrepancy on December 30th - A Must-See! | Alpha Morning Report

December 29th Market Key Intelligence, How Much Did You Miss?

Ten People Redefining the Power Boundaries of Crypto in 2025
From Wall Street to the White House, from Silicon Valley to Shenzhen, a new power network is taking shape.
Key Market Intelligence on December 30th, how much did you miss out on?
Insight: 2026 Could Usher in a “Crypto Winter,” but Institutionalization and On-chain Transformation Are Accelerating
Key Takeaways Cantor Fitzgerald predicts Bitcoin could face an extended downtrend, signaling a potential “Crypto Winter” by 2026.…
Caixin: Digital RMB Wallet Balances to Begin Earning Interest in 2026
Key Takeaways: Starting January 1, 2026, digital RMB wallets will earn interest on balances. The operational structure will…
Key Market Information Discrepancy on December 30th – A Must-See!
Key Takeaways Meta’s massive acquisition of Manus is poised to reshape the tech landscape, indicating significant growth in…
Cryptocurrency Trends and Insights: Navigating the 2025 Landscape
Key Takeaways Cryptocurrency continues to evolve rapidly, with new trends reshaping the market. Blockchain technology’s applications extend beyond…
Lighter: Airdrop Successful and Token Trading Imminent
Key Takeaways: The Lighter Discord community recently announced the successful distribution of LIT tokens, marking the beginning of…
Popular coins
Latest Crypto News
Customer Support:@weikecs
Business Cooperation:@weikecs
Quant Trading & MM:[email protected]
VIP Services:[email protected]